Personal Insurance Account Manager - Buffalo or Rochester, NY (Hybrid)

Lawley
Buffalo, NY

Personal Insurance Account Manager – Buffalo or Rochester, NY (Hybrid)

Apply Now

Share this...

Location: Buffalo, NYRochester, NY Type: Full Time

Due to recent growth/acquisitions, Lawley is in search of a Personal Insurance Account Manager for their Buffalo or Rochester, NY locations, servicing a Connecticut book of business! This position would focus on servicing an existing book of business, advising clients on coverages, as well as completing adds, endorsements, cancels, and binds. This position focuses on service and sales, as we encourage Account Managers to cross sell and upsell accounts. The ideal candidate has experience in personal insurance servicing, in both home and auto, and a P&C license. Lawley is a family owned organization built on strong core values. We offer work/life balance, amazing benefits, competitive compensation, and more! We also offer an in office/hybrid schedule once training is complete. If you have both home and auto experience, and the desire to join one of the best places to work in insurance, please consider applying today!

Fundamental Components of the Job:

• Manage an assigned book of existing business, focusing on growth and retention. The Account Manager will routinely conduct consultative conversations with our clients and prospects to ensure all coverage needs are addressed
• Develop, quote and sell Personal Insurance to new and existing clients
• Work within designated timelines to provide superior customer service to retain our clients, as well as referrals and new business opportunities
• Responsibilities for processing endorsements and creating insurance documents as needed

Other functions of the job:
• Establish and maintain professional relationships with carriers and clients
• Expand and grow in your role when supporting miscellaneous duties as requested

Skills/Traits That We Value for This Role:

• Insurance experience in customer service or account management for 3 years or more
• Property/Casualty License
• Relevant knowledge of insurance products, documents and usages
• Computers skills are a must, Applied & EPIC experiences is preferred
• Ability to work well independently and on a team
• Incredible attention to detail and organizational skills
• Open to continuing education, college degree preferred
• Positive attitude, even in a fast paced environment
• A passion to make customers and coworkers feel important and valued
• Capability to work quickly and efficiently
• Methodical, yet swift decision making skills
• Precise verbal and written communication skills, even under time constraints

What’s in It for You?

A bit about Lawley!
• We are not a call center environment
• We achieve success by building genuine relationships together, with our teams and clients
• We are a family owned insurance broker (70+ years!)
• We are deeply committed to the communities we serve and love to get involved
• We work hard and play hard!!!

Why Lawley?
• Competitive salary and referral bonuses!
• Expansive Benefits (Medical, Dental, Vision—and SO many more)
• 3 weeks of PTO (prorated based on start date) AND a generous holiday schedule – available 1st day!
• Company 401K contribution received starting Day 1 (for participants 21+ years old)
• Educational support, career development, and growth opportunities
• Job Security (we’ve never had a lay-off, even during the pandemic)
• Flexibility, including hybrid schedules! Business hours 8am-4:30pm
• Comfortable, family-oriented culture, with an emphasis on work life balance
• Unlimited Volunteer Time Off opportunities (so you can assist in serving our communities)
• Fulfilling opportunities that align with your career path and our business needs

The compensation range for this position takes many factors into consideration including but not limited to: years of experience/training, skill set, and licenses/designations. It is not typical for an individual to be hired near the top of the range for a position as circumstances and location can vary in every hiring situation. A reasonable estimate of the current range is $51,498.15 to $85,830.25.

Apply Now

Posted 2025-11-27

Recommended Jobs

Member Services Rep Floater NY

Planet Fitness
Dunkirk, NY

Position: Member Services Rep - Floater We are searching for a motivated Member Services Representative to join our team! BILINGUAL English/Spanish are encouraged to apply!  As a member of our s…

View Details
Posted 2025-11-14

Political Producer - Spectrum News NY1

Spectrum
New York, NY

Position Type: Full Time Location: New York, New York Date Posted: Date posted 10/29/2025 Areas of interest: Editorial, News, Production Requisition Number: 2025-64228 Business unit: Spectrum…

View Details
Posted 2025-10-30

Registered Nurse

Community Health Center of Buffalo
Buffalo, NY

**Job Summary:** Join our team at the Community Health Center of Buffalo (CHCB) and make a real difference in the lives of our patients! We are seeking a passionate and dedicated Registered Nurse t…

View Details
Posted 2025-11-27

Senior Software Engineer

Nastech Consulting
Smithtown, NY

Job Brief: The business is looking for a Software Engineer to join our geographically dispersed team as an early hire in our fast growing startup. If you are excited about building scalable, highl…

View Details
Posted 2025-11-25

Performance Tester (New York City, Metropolitan Area)

RCI Technologies
New York, NY

RCI Technologies is looking for a QA performance Analyst for our prestigious client in New York City. Responsibilities: ~Certify the client’s application code releases and report any performance imp…

View Details
Posted 2025-11-27

Infrastructure and Cloud Engineer - NBS

Nelnet
Albany, NY

Nelnet Business Services (NBS), a division of Nelnet, Inc., provides payment technology, education services, and learning management solutions to education and faith-based organizations, serving mor…

View Details
Posted 2025-11-27

Senior Manager of Administration, Science

New York Botanical Garden
Bronx, NY

NYBG Job Description   Title Reports to Senior Manager of Administration, Science Dean of Science   Position Summary: The New York Botanical Garden is seeking a proactive, init…

View Details
Posted 2025-11-27

Customer Service Representative

SGS Consulting
New York, NY

Job Responsibilities: Serve as the first point of contact for customers via phone and email Route inquiries appropriately and ensure prompt responses Follow ISO9001 Customer Service Procedur…

View Details
Posted 2025-11-14

Busser

Darden Concepts, Inc.
Bronx, NY

$11.00 per hour - $11.00 per hour plus tips. Our Winning Family Starts With You!  Check out these great benefits! ~ Flexible schedules to help you balance other life commitments (school, ch…

View Details
Posted 2025-10-31

Lead Product Manager - Enterprise Architecture

Rokt
New York, NY

mParticle by Rokt is widely recognized as one of the leading customer data platforms, serving hundreds of global brands and helping them turn data to insights, and insights to action. Built on top o…

View Details
Posted 2025-11-25