Paralegal - insurance litigation

Pillinger Miller Tarallo LLP
Elmsford, NY

Defense Litigation Paralegal

New York Metro Area law firm with national practice seeks paralegal with at least three (3) year’s defense litigation experience. The ideal candidate will have a strong background in insurance defense litigation and possess exceptional organizational and communication skills. This position offers the opportunity to work on a diverse range of cases and collaborate with attorneys to provide outstanding legal support. Notary Public license a plus. Paralegal Degree or Certificate strongly preferred.

Essential Functions

  • Review and analyze discovery documents, case materials and correspondence.
  • Draft legal documents including third-party summons and complaints, notices of appearance, discovery responses, discovery demands, subpoenas, stipulations, consents to change attorneys, notice of entry, and other legal documents and correspondence.
  • Assist with depositions.
  • Obtain and maintain medical and other records.
  • Coordinate investigations, expert examinations and inspections.
  • Organize and maintain file documents.
  • Assist with motions and preparation of exhibits.
  • E-file documents with NYSCEF and PACER.
  • Assist with pre-trial and trial preparation.

Applicants should possess the following:

  • Strong oral and written communication and organization skills
  • Prioritization skills with the ability to multi-task
  • Ability to work well in a fast-paced environment
  • Attention to detail
  • Experience in Microsoft office
  • Experience in Prolaw is a plus!

Qualifications :

  • Paralegal Certificate/degree preferred
  • At least 3 years’ experience working at a defense law firm
  • Ability to complete trial prep work
  • Assisting in court filings and basic motion practice
  • Handling a No-Fault calendar
  • Having an understanding of the court system - when, where, why, and how to file certain motions
  • Having strong research skills
  • Having familiarity with NY courts
  • Having experience reviewing medical and accident reports
  • Having client contact experience

Other Duties
Please note this job description is not designed to cover or contain a comprehensive listing of activities, duties, or responsibilities that are required of the employee for this job. Duties, responsibilities, and activities may change at any time with or without notice.

Please direct your resume, office location you are applying for and salary requirements to Shirley Marsh ([email protected]), Paralegal Supervisor.

Job Type :
Full-time (with Hybrid schedule available at this time)
Hybrid Schedule Subject to Change

Salary Range :
$55,000.00 - $70,000.00 per year - Commensurate with Experience

PMT Office Locations:
Elmsford, NY | Syracuse, NY | Philadelphia, PA | New York, NY

We offer a competitive benefits package to all our employees, including:

  • Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance
  • Employee Assistance Program (EAP)
  • Family Medical Leave (FMLA)
  • Paid Family Leave (PFL)
  • Domestic Partner Benefits (Same Sex)
  • Short and Long-term Disability
  • Firm-paid Life Insurance
  • Employee Paid Accidental Death and Dismemberment Insurance
  • Voluntary Life Insurance
  • Pre-tax Parking and Transit Programs – Commuter Benefits
  • Pre-tax Medical and Dependent Care Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA and HRA)
  • 401(k) Retirement Savings Plan
  • 401(k) Matching Program
  • 12 paid holidays per year
  • 3 weeks of PTO per year to start
  • Bereavement Policy
  • Jury Duty

About Us:
Pillinger Miller Tarallo began in 2002 with a handful of lawyers representing insurance clients in
New York and has grown into over 100 lawyers located throughout New York, Connecticut, New
Jersey and Pennsylvania. We have been able to achieve this successful growth by providing highly-experienced representation to our clients in all areas of civil litigation.

Our primary objective is the swift, cost-effective resolution of cases with the most favorable outcome possible for our clients.

Our Firm is AV rated by Martindale-Hubbell, the highest rating achieved only by a select group of law firms after a rigorous screening process.

Our attorneys have handled thousands of cases across numerous practice areas throughout the
Northeast. Moreover, we are known as the “go to” trial firm since our attorneys have tried over

500 cases since the formation of the firm. Our approach to each and every case is to provide not only sound legal counsel, but also to ensure excellent client service. The foregoing principles have guided us over the years and have laid a foundation for our attorneys to build upon for the future.

Job Type: Full-time

Pay: $55,000.00 - $70,000.00 per year

Benefits:

  • 401(k)
  • 401(k) matching
  • AD&D insurance
  • Dental insurance
  • Disability insurance
  • Employee assistance program
  • Employee discount
  • Flexible schedule
  • Flexible spending account
  • Free parking
  • Health insurance
  • Health savings account
  • Life insurance
  • Paid sick time
  • Paid time off
  • Parental leave
  • Referral program
  • Retirement plan
  • Vision insurance
  • Wellness program
  • Work from home

Application Question(s):

  • Salary range

Work Location: Hybrid remote in Elmsford, NY 10523

Posted 2025-10-18

Recommended Jobs

Formulary Operations Pharmacist - Medicare

The Phoenix Health Search Group
New York, NY

~Description:One of the PBM Industry’s fastest-growing players is seeking a strategic  PharmD Formulary Operations Pharmacist-Medicare professional responsible for providing operational support for t…

View Details
Posted 2025-08-15

Substance abuse prevention and specialist

New York City Department of Education
New York, NY

Substance Abuse Prevention and Intervention Specialist Level 2 - Bronx Early College Academy for Teaching and Learning (09X324) Posted Date: Oct 3, 2025 Deadline: Oct 17, 2025 Job Details …

View Details
Posted 2025-10-18

Dedicated Class A CDL Truck Driver- Drop & Hook!

Swift Refrigerated
New York State

SWIFT DEDICATED REFRIGERATED OPPORTUNITY Lots of Drop & Hook Freight! Advantages of Swift Dedicated Refrigerated Fleet Interested in driving with Swift Refrigerated?  Please text DRIVESWIFT to 2…

View Details
Posted 2025-08-06

Assistant Residence Manager (NY)

THE CENTER FOR FAMILY SUPPORT INC
Bronx, NY

Overview: The Assistant Residence Manager will assist the Residence Manager in overseeing the daily operation of the assigned residence; including providing direct supervision of Direct Support Profe…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-30

Adventure Awaits: Pediatric Nursing in Scenic Elmira!

NurseRecruiter
Elmira, NY

Registered Nurse - Pediatric - Travel - (Peds RN - Pedi RN) Embark on an unforgettable journey as a Pediatric Nurse in scenic Elmira, New York! Experience a warm, kid-friendly unit with a supportive …

View Details
Posted 2025-07-30

Director - Crossix Analytics Services

Veeva Systems
New York, NY

Veeva Systems is a mission-driven organization and pioneer in industry cloud, helping life sciences companies bring therapies to patients faster. As one of the fastest-growing SaaS companies in histo…

View Details
Posted 2025-07-31

Early Career, Associate Product Manager (2026)

Figma
New York, NY

Figma is growing our team of passionate creatives and builders on a mission to make design accessible to all. Figma’s platform helps teams bring ideas to life—whether you're brainstorming, creating a…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-15

Generator Service Technician II

Stark Tech
Albany, NY

Advance your career with the Stark Tech team. We'll shape your future together! Stark Tech is a total optimization provider of facilities and energy solutions. Stark Tech leads the market in pro…

View Details
Posted 2025-10-18